China Tibet, the "Roof of the World" (Bod to
Tibetans, Xizang to the Chinese), has exerted a pull
of almost supernatural proportions over travellers
for many centuries. However, it is today a sad,
subjugated colony of China. The scenery has a
majesty and grandeur that are spellbinding, the
religious monuments and practices are overwhelmingly
picturesque and moving, and the Tibetan people are
welcoming and wonderful, but this is a previously
proud and independent nation in thrall to a foreign
power: look just a little below the surface and it
is all too apparent that Tibet's past has been
tragic, its present is painful, and the future looks
bleak.
This doesn't mean you should stay away, however.
While tourism provides legitimacy as well as
foreign currency to the Chinese government, many
people, the Dalai Lama among them, believe that
travellers should visit Tibet to learn all they can
of the country and its people. Although the daily
bureaucratic irritations for independent visitors
can sometimes seem overwhelming, official Chinese
policy is to increase the number of tourists, and
hence tourism earnings, in Tibet. While the Chinese
prefer easily controllable, high-rolling tour
parties rather than the less malleable, less
lucrative budget travellers, they are, for the
moment, prepared to tolerate both.
The isolation of Tibet has long stirred the
imagination of the West, yet until the British,
under the command of Younghusband, invaded in 1904,
only a trickle of bold eccentrics, adventurers and
the odd missionary had succeeded in getting close to
Lhasa, and then only at serious risk to their lives,
for it was firm Tibetan policy to exclude all
influence from the outside world. So great was the
uncertainty about the geographical nature of the
country even 150 years ago that the British in India
despatched carefully trained spies, known as pundits,
to walk the length and breadth of the country,
counting their footsteps with rosaries and mapping
as they went. When Younghusband's invasion force
finally reached Lhasa they were, perhaps inevitably,
disappointed. One journalist accompanying them
wrote:
If one approached within a league of Lhasa,
saw the glittering domes of the Potala and turned
back without entering the precincts one might still
imagine an enchanted city. It was in fact an
unsanitary slum. In the pitted streets pools of
rainwater and piles of refuse were everywhere: the
houses were mean and filthy, the stench pervasive.
Pigs and ravens competed for nameless delicacies in
open sewers.
Since 1950 Tibet has become much more accessible
with approaches eased by plane links with Chengdu
and Kathmandu. Today's visitors are perhaps more
worldly than to expect a romantic Shangri-la, but
there is no doubt that many people are surprised by
the heavy military and civilian Chinese presence,
the modern apartments and factories alongside
traditional Tibetan rural lifestyles and
monasteries.
The massive Tibetan plateau , at an
average height of 4500m above sea level, is guarded
on all sides by towering mountain ranges: the
Himalaya separates Tibet from India, Nepal and
Bhutan to the south, the Karakoram from Pakistan to
the west and the Kunlun from Xinjiang to the north.
To the east, dividing Tibet from Sichuan and Yunnan,
an extensive series of subsidiary ranges covers
almost a thousand kilometres. The plateau is also
birthplace to some of the greatest rivers of Asia,
with the Yangzi, Mekong, Yellow and Salween rising
in the east, and the Indus, Brahmaputra, Sutlej and
some feeder rivers of the Ganges in the west near
Mount Kailash.
Covering a massive 1.2 million square kilometres,
today's Tibetan Autonomous Region (TAR) is
but a shadow of the former Tibetan lands. The old
area, sometimes referred to as Greater Tibet or
Ethnographic Tibet, was carved up by the Chinese
following their invasion in 1950, when the Amdo and
Kham regions were absorbed into Qinghai, Sichuan,
Gansu and Yunnan provinces. The TAR consists only of
the West and Central (U-Tsang) regions of Greater
Tibet and divides into four geographical areas. The
northern and largest portion is the almost
uninhabited Chang Tang , a rocky desert
averaging 4000m altitude, where winter temperatures
can fall to minus 44°C. South of this is the mountainous
grazing area , land that cannot support settled
agriculture, inhabited by the wide-ranging nomadic
people with their herds of yaks, sheep and goats.
The southern valleys , sandwiched between
this nomad area and the Himalaya along the
southern border, are the most hospitable for human
habitation. Not surprisingly, this is the most
populated area and where visitors spend the majority
of their time, particularly in the extensive valley
system of the Tsangpo River (Brahmaputra) and its
tributaries.
There has been heavy Han migration into the
region since 1950, and although it is impossible to
know how many Chinese live here now, it is likely
they will soon outnumber Tibetans, if they don't
already. The situation is most marked in the cities,
where the greatest opportunities exist: not only are
the numbers of Han increasing all the time, but they
are becoming economically dominant too.
It's worth bearing a few things in mind while
you're here. Many of the Chinese who have come to
Tibet are poor people trying to make a life for
themselves and their families - they may have little
knowledge or understanding of the wider political
implications of their presence here. Also, life in
Tibet has taken its toll on Tibetans, and there have
been instances of Tibetans asking for Dalai Lama
pictures or asking foreigners to take letters to
relatives outside the country and then turning the
foreigners in to the security forces to be deported.
Be careful whom you trust, but also be aware of the
harm you may be doing. Everyday conversations are
going to cause no damage, but if you are seen to be
asking a lot of politically loaded questions about
sensitive issues then not only are you putting
yourself at risk but any Tibetans who talk to you
could be in danger long after you have left the
country.
Tibet offers some of the most awe-inspiring scenery
in the world, and the sheer scale of the
high-altitude valleys, mountains and lakes in which
human habitation is but a speck on the landscape is
humbling. Lhasa , Shigatse and Gyantse
offer the most accessible monasteries and temples
- the Jokhang, Tashilunpo and the Kumbum
respectively - and are also tourist-friendly cities
with the biggest range of facilities in the region.
The Potala Palace in Lhasa remains an
enduring image of Tibet in the Western mind and
should on no account be missed, and there are plenty
of smaller sights in the city to keep anyone busy
for several days. Farther afield, the Yarlung
and Chongye valleys to the southeast boast
temples and ancient monuments, and the ancient
walled monastery of Samye is easily combined
with these. The tourist corridor between Zhangmu on
the Nepalese border and Lhasa is relatively
well-trodden these days, although by no means
overcrowded, and offers side-trips to the huge
Mongolian-style monastery at Sakya and to Everest
Base Camp .